Dear Qwerty,
One can claim that the Rebbe is perfect even though he sinned and still play your game. All inferences are your own. Nobody has to think that their beliefs follow your logic. People have illogical beliefs and there is nothing you or anyone can do about it. Some believe that the only way to achieve perfection is through sin.
I didn’t dodge anything. I love these topics.
Beliefs that are antithecial to Judaism includes blurring the distinction between weekdays and Shabbos. How extreme are you in theological exclusions? The Realm of Torah Judaism is what in the words of Chaal?
I pointed out on the PEW thread (As well as many times in the past.) that we do not have any thought police of an individual Jew anywhere in halacha. It is only an issue when in a leadership role.
Jews for J would not be in the fold. They are not included in ‘Amisecha’. Many sources for that. But losing Olam Habaah over beliefs does not take one out of the fold. We still are required to treat them like Jews as long as there is no spiritual danger in associating with them.