“6) Brooklyn is more than 12 mil. Rav Moshe never meant that Boro Park alone or Flatbush alone have 600k. Any statician would laugh at the idea of Rav Moshe’s teshuvah being a source for an exact number. Nowhere does Rav Moshe say to take a count.
At some point I’ll just give up on trying to get answers and I will post the whole thing myself.”
Rav Moshe repeated it twice, he clearly meant it but was mislead. Please, the entire teshuvah (87-88) is regarding counts. Please stop making up arguments on the go. Learn the inyan prior to making grand statements. There is no doubt from you arguments that it wasn’t that you were offline, but only that you tried to learn the inyan a little, but unfortunately failed miserably. You will not give up trying to answer, you do not have what to answer. Learn the inyan.
Menu