AviraDeArah, my 1st statement was a bit tongue in cheek although I apologize because tone is almost impossible to read online. Just because everyone does something obviously doesn’t make it okay.
My point was more if there was something seriously problematic from a Jewish perspective I doubt so many people here would have read and enjoyed them. I certainly intentionally avoided reading the Narnia series by CS Lewis. Regret for reading them does not seem to be universal either. Are there concerns with the HP series yes clearly. Is it the worst thing for a Jewish kid to read not by a long shot. I don’t see it as having only one right answer but maybe that’s just so I’m always right. 😉
Menu