Reply To: Question of an ignorant, closed-minded Lubavitcher

Qwerty (sigh),

I have stated in this thread that I only criticize Chabad. That’s a fact. I never said anything negative about black hatters. That’s an outright lie…
To Menachem Shmei You’re on notice. I want you to present evidence that I’m anti black hatter. All my Rabbonim wear black hats including those from YU.

I didn’t say that you’re anti black hatter. I said that you have a problem with black hatters.

You claim to have never said anything negative about black hatters? Nu nu. This is a machlokes b’metzius, so no point of arguing (שדי חמד מע’ מ כלל קסד).

“To Menachem Shmei’s credit, he’s able to understand that I have a healthy relationship with my Rabbonim… Unfortunately the black hatters are so dogmatic that anyone who veers from their concept of how a Jew must act is labeled off the derech.”

The Rebbe makes…

In the CR, I would never speak so disrespectfully about any Litvisher gadol, even if I strongly disagree with him, and even if I think he’s not actually a true gadol.
If someone is looked up to as a manhig by many frum Yidden, I wouldn’t talk about him to his talmidim like this.

you promoted the notion that the Rebbe is god

You will not find ONE POST where I said that the Rebbe was G-d!
All I did was insist that you’re misunderstanding the quote “עצמות ומהות אליין ווי ער איז אריינגעשטעלט אין א גוף”.
The quotes I brought were to show that such a statement is not so rare in traditional Jewish literature.
Nothing more, nothing less.
Find me a post that says differently.

Sechel83 finally gave up, why don’t you do the same? The fat lady has sung.

How will it help you in life if I give up?
I was having a discussion. You joined in middle. You are free to leave.
You still don’t feel that you can put me on your “checkmate list” until I leave the thread for good?