@avira: “Get real. Chazal mean no such thing and you know it” well said you decide what chazal mean?! so i dont see how we can have a discussion, i believe in chazal!
@yankel
Question to be asked is the following : Do we all agree that habad came up with new stuff in the last 60-70 years ?
Yes or no ? yes, so? (every sect of jews came up with new stuff)
Did habad at anytime in its 250 years plus of existence at any time or location organize a gathering for hachtarat meleh hamashiach ?
Yes or no ? i heard there was meant to be one yud shvat 5753, is that an issue? Whats the problem? Its against halacha?
now in order to understand the reason for it, requires a lot of background, but its based on what i mentioned before that a melech can only become melech thru the nation accepting his malchus. See maamarim for rosh hashana in likutai torah, mitzvas minoi melech in derech mitzvosecha.
Did habad or any of its rebeim , including the other offshoots/branches [like niezin,liadi kapust etc] ever have their rabanim issue a public kol koreh for the public to accept their leader as mashiach ?
Yes or no? I understand your question is why did the rebbe? Simple cuz the time of moshiach came!
Those questions do not pertain to opinions.
They pertain to facts.
Facts are either true or untrue.
So to all of you , honest people , out there – Can we first get an unqualified and simple one word response to those questions ?
Menu