What is impossible to understand about the satmar Shitta is the following –
Any open eyed facts based assessment of the situation in EY will arrive at the same conclusion.
1] The yehudim in EY are surrounded by bloodthirsty savages who would commit the worst atrocities if not stopped by force.
2] The only practical and effective force available is the IDF.
3] The only way of enabling the existence of the IDF , is the existence of the Medina.
Doesn’t it follow then , that the existence of the medina is the only barrier in front of a millions times of pikuach nefesh ?
Why should I care [in the context of p/n] who, or in what way established the medina , or who governs the medina or how the medina is being governed ?
Pikuach nefesh is Pikuach nefesh. Full Stop.
Let’s say it was the tsionims fault. Let’s say. Therefore, are we not obligated to act in the face of mass p/n ?
Does Hatole anywhere in the world , not do anything possible to save any yid ?
EVEN IF IT MIGHT BE THE CHOLE’S OWN FAULT ?
If hatsole is obligated to act in the defense against P/N , without inquiring whether it is the victims own fault , why would any yid not be obligated in the same ?
So why is the existence of the medina [in our constellation] not absolutely MANDATED by the torah ?
The only possible idea would be the mahaal who is reputed to have written that the 3 shavuot are meant to be kept EVEN AT THE RISK OF OUR OWN LIFE.
Since when do we pakan like a maharal as a daat yahid , NOT MENTIONED IN ANY OF THE noe”sei keilim in sh’a who deal halacha lema’ase ?
If anyone has the Mareh hamakom for this maharal?
Thanks