yankel, you are at the great madregah of Chaim Brisker’s family member (*) who called a doctor for a sick kid on shabbos. Chaim Brisker suggested adding logs to the fire so that the doctor could see better. The family member started evaluating in his mind whether it is necessary to do that or the doctor can do without. R Chaim got annoyed and went to add logs himself. With your shitah, there would be nobody to lead YU later on …
(*) the way I recall the story was written, it is clear who the person is, but the story does not name him.