Spot on,
That’s faulty logic
They benefit from paved roads, garbage collection, sewer system, mail service etc.
They’re taxes pay those things too
It’s like the mashal with the guy collecting tzedakah for his yeshiva and comes in a fancy car, the gvir says “I’m not giving money for your fancy car, but the answer is that whatever your kvanah is that’s what you give it to
So too here