Home › Forums › Decaffeinated Coffee › Chabad Media Won › Reply To: Chabad Media Won
@qwerty, yserbius
on lichtenstein show 102, the following Rabbonim were asked about their opinion on chabad Rabbi Shmuel Kamenetsky, Rabbi Nissan Kaplan, Rabbi Hershel Shachter, Rabbi Menachem Mendel Shafran, Rabbi Dovid Cohen, Rabbi Dovid Yosef,
they all said there is NOTHING wrong with those who say the rebbe is moshiach, final.
in kuntres shmo shel moshiach which is a sefer about if moshiach can be from the dead, the following Rabbonim gave haskomos: Rabbi Yitzchok Breitewitz, Rabbi Zev Leff
you want to call all these Rabbonim apikorsim ch”v?? thats what you are saying
(about what they say that those who say the Rebbe is g-d ch”v are minim, we went thru this many times, but these Rabbonim themselves many learn the Rebbe’s torah (you can find them talking about it on a recent interview,) Many of them are very close to chabad, Rav shmuel Kamenetsky gave a haskama to tzivos hashem Yahadus book, full of sichos of the Rebbe, and they never came out against the rebbe himself in public.
so obviously they have a bit more brains than you and know that what the rebbe said in the sicha, is the same thing written in gemara, medrash, zohar, yerushalmi, and it just needs to be understood properly and not twisted. those who understand it in a twisted way (or for that matter understand the gemara, medrash, pesukim in chumash etc, litterly or twisted, are also minim.)