Dr. Pepper is correct. If you collect reports of the experiences of those who fought and expulsion and won, the best results were short lived. I actually witnessed this many times, and have NEVER seen the restoration of the yeshiva placement last. All that Hanhalah does, if compelled to retract the expulsion, is put the talmid under undue scrutiny. The slightest belief that there was any form of imperfect behavior is grounds to repeat the expulsion, this time with no hope for reconsideration. You may inquire from the tzaddikim who volunteer huge amounts of time and effort to help with yeshiva placements. You will find that what I just said here will be repeated by all of them.
Menu