qwerty613
I don’t know which question you are referring to, sorry
@ always ask: This book has enormous number of citations, I never saw anything documented as well as this sefer. S
So great that’s my point. (I wrote that he makes up stuff, I came acroos a hakria vihakdusha he openly twisted the words (even though he quotes the source) and therefore calls it kefira. (you can check the original yourself)
Lemayseh
Great point – it is very important to know that the Agudas Harabbonim, of which Rav Moshe was President in his later years, had a Lubavitcher secretary, by the name of Avrohom Shmuel Lewin,
Meaning they did not have an issue with Chabad. Reb moshe passed away before the big focus on the rebbe was moshiach started, but you can NOT decide what he would have held. As I mentioned before reb moshe backed the rebbe’s mivtzoim and the parade even though R’ shach wrote against it. The sicha that the rebbe is atzmus inclothed in a body was said over 30 yrs before R moshe was niftar, and printed over 20 yrs – in the 60s.
People keep claiming that we believe the rebbe is g-d, and that sicha is kefira ch”v, well all the gedolim were around then.
@yeserbius Neither of you have taken up my challenge: Go find a RANDOM selection of non-Chabad Rabbonim and ask them if it’s OK to believe that a dead man is Moshiach. If you want, you can even start with Rav Breitowitz SHLITA
There is a video of Rav breitowitz talking about the lubavitchers who believe the rebbe is moshiach, its on youtube, he said there is nothing wrong as mentioned before he wrote a haskama to a sefer too
@square root: see what I wrote to lemayse.
@yankel berel : in the times of the baal hatanya, the misnagdim accused chassidim of praying to the rebbe, the rebbe as being a cult leader, it being a new religion – go learn history, read yehoshu mundshin’s books, he brings all the Russian documents from the arrest of the baal hatanya. It’s a fact
Today people without opening up a Tanya, decide that the baal hatanya went with the litvishe derecho, its only today all the Chabad things started. Go open a Tanya
I’ll make a bet, anyone who brings a sicha, maamer, letter, etc of the Rebbe (My rebbe) that I can not find a makor in the seforim of the baal hatanya or his son the miteler rebbe – ill resign from being a chassid (I would give you money if you want $500)