To the group
This morning I made a simple request to Menachem Shmei to actually formulate a question which I’ll try to answer. Shmei cites my request and continues to call me a liar for not answering his non-existent question(s). This is bordering on schizophrenia territory.
To Menachem Shmei
The moderators and myself are Yirei Shomayim. We understand the gravity of denigrating a Godol B’Yisroel. Therefore I would never say the things I’ve said about Oso Harebbe unless I was absolutely certain that my contentions are correct. In addition I have spoken to my Rabbonim and they are in complete agreement with me. Moreover, the moderators obviously agree with me or they wouldn’t print what I’ve said. As I’ve stated on numerous occasions, the Rebbe rejected open Gemaras because they were at odds with his agenda.