Reply To: Chabad Media Won

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Chabad Media Won Reply To: Chabad Media Won

#2312610
philosopher
Participant

Menachem Shmei, my last comment to you was not so clearly written, therefore i am clarifying my answer to you in this post.

2. Here’s what you wrote: “(…Based on that hekesh he proves that just as they are alive, so too he is alive even though facts seem otherwise.) Rashi (on Gemara) explains that he was only buried because they thought he was dead, but really he was alive.” Do you really not see that you are totally contradicting yourself!!? You claimed the entire time that Rashi said the Yaacov Avinu was PHYSICALLY ALIVE and now you say that Rashi “explains that HE WAS ONLY BURIED because they thought he was dead, but really he was alive”. So now you are changing what you claimed Rashi says and now you are admiting what I had said all along that Rashi does not contradict the posuk that Yaacov’s body expired (and therefore he was buried) and he is not saying that Yaacov is physically alive!!! Over what exactly are you still arguing with me on this?!