Reply To: Chabad Media Won

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Chabad Media Won Reply To: Chabad Media Won

#2316442
ARSo
Participant

I’m not sure this went through, so I’m sending it again. My apologies if it’s doubled-up.

Qwerty: didn’t check the Hitler comparison with him, but Dr. Berger agrees with it so that’s reliable.

Where does Dr Berger agree with your statement that the LR learnt from H ym”sh the concept of the master race? I don’t believe he ever said it, and I believe you are a liar!

The challenge is for you to name a living non-Chabad Rabbi who says Yaakov Avinu is still physically alive.

1. Why non-living? The Rif on Ein Yaakov isn’t good enough for you?
2. The question is NOT who says Yaakov Avinu is still physically alive. The question is if Rashi held that, and he did according to the Riv et al AND ARTSCROLL. I stress that because you keep avoiding the point that Artscroll says it.

You said that if the discussion was Menachem’s belief in the LR and Moshiach you would disagree with everything he wrote. I asked you why you would disagree with him. I’m sure he has phony sources for this garbage.

I disagree with him because I believe the LR did not fulfill ANY of the criteria required of Mashiach, and that he was not worthy of it anyhow. If he has PHONY sources, then that’s another reason I would not agree with him!

As for the Rabbi Akiva quote, bli Neder I’ll see my Rav tonight and get it. If I’m wrong I’ll admit it.

That will be a first.

Finally as I’ve said numerous not all Lubavitchers are idolaters and even those who are largely keep it to themselves so there’s no problem davening with them

So it is only prohibited to daven with idolaters who publicly profess their idolatry?! Do you always make up your own Torah?