@ somejew
Re r akiva
there is no question at all
I do not have any questions
.
.
the question is on you
you claim that no man made hishtadlut is to be made even by mashiach to bring the ge’oula
.
.
then how could r akiva and the rambam consider ben kochba as mashiach ?
he was ruled out only when he died
he should have been ruled out straight away — on the grounds of his man made attempts to bring the ge’oula ???
.
Shma minah that the ge’oula can come via man made efforts .
.
what exactly is incoherent in this post ???
…
.