Pashuteh – I find your mischaracterization of chareidim as repulsive and unworthy of response. I’ll bet you wouldn’t dare talk about blacks, or GENERALIZE about them, the way you talk about your brothers.
cantoresq – Please. Porter is a FICTION novel writer. Your going to take a novelist over an anthropologist? (And because some dead link gave you misinformation to boot!) I must say you betray an agenda, not a search for the truth. Prove me wrong please.