Reply To: Chivalry & Yiddishkeit: A Foreign Concept

Home Forums Bais Medrash Chivalry & Yiddishkeit: A Foreign Concept Reply To: Chivalry & Yiddishkeit: A Foreign Concept

#641840
000646
Participant

WILL HILL,

You said,

“Now that this issue has been broached, it is an interesting observation that had the Titanic C’V been a Jewish sail, al pi halacha they would have had to save the men first”

Seriously what on earth is the matter with you?

The reason why on a sinking ship they would get the woman and children off first is because the men are usually physically stronger and have a better chance at survival (if they need to hang on to debris or whatever) then both of these groups. Nobody ever knows for sure if there is zero chance of survival in these situations.

If you had been on the Titanic you would have got off the ship first and left your wife and child to fend for themselves??

Also a man is supposed to BE A MAN and protect his wife and children NOT the other way around (if you think someone has broken into your house and you don’t have a phone do you send your wife or child downstairs to confront the intruder or do you go down??)