Reply To: Children at a Second Marriage

I don’t know, but I think that when one hears a p’sak from the Godol Hador, that should suffice. “

note oomis, as per our previous discussion, you ended the above with quote marks but put none at the beginning…80

“Rabbi Yosef Shalom Elyashiv, shlita, was asked about this custom. He gave the following EXPLANATION (my emphasis): ” (direct quote from Artchill)

Cholent….My understanding of what Artchill posted is not that it was R’ Elayshiv’s Shlitah’s P’SAK, but his explanation (p’sak is your word). There is a huge difference between the two. I would hope you were not implying that I was disrespecting the Rov,as I most certainly was not. I merely commented that it could be looked at in either way, if one looked at the kibud Av aspect for the live parent. At the end of the day, so far all I have heard is that this is a MINHAG, not a halacha.