Reply To: Starbucks Story

Home Forums Inspiration / Mussar Starbucks Story Reply To: Starbucks Story

#672342
cantoresq
Member

Btw cantorsq, Even if we assume for a moment that your interpretation AND recollection of what you say is the Chazon Ish’s position IS correct, are you saying you accept the positions of the Chazon Ish across the board, or only where it suits you — and you will pick and choose responsa from various scholars that meet YOUR liking, for every different question?

In other words, if for example I show you a teshuva from the Chazon Ish that states that one must wear a hat and jacket during the entire course of davening and bentching, with a minyan or without, will you accept it and start following it (if you aren’t already), or will you find another shitta to your suiting for that circumstance and disregard the Chazon Ish’s position in that case?

___________________________

Joseph I do as all Jews do. I listen to that which resonates with my sense of what is reasonable. We all do, you included. So please spare me this poor example of a plea of some neo-Kantian categorical imperative.