I am not endorsing this system I am just commenting on some aspects of it for those who might agree with it;
Scoring in a numbers system would not be good because such scioring could allow for someone to get tzedokka when the giver specifically wanted to give to somneone who did not have that aspect that he wanted to exclude.
If someone smoked for example but scored perfectly on all the other qualifications but the giver really hated the idea of smoking more then anything else his money might still go to that smoker.
Also how about a qualification regarding how much they help others and how much or little, they say Loshon Hara?