Reply To: Mental Health

Home Forums Health & Fitness Mental Health Reply To: Mental Health

#687546
philosopher
Member

Health, answer me clearly

1. Aren’t there or are there people with borderline personality disorder, bipolar, and clinical depression and other mental diseases and they are frum?

2. Do you think that those who are diagnosed with mental diseases would agree to be called shoitim?

“We were judging them up at the time they went off and at that time they were keeping mitzvos.”

I thought you’re not judging them? Anyway that’s you’re interpretation of the application of halacha.

“It seems you need to look down on all not-frum Jews, esp. the teenagers”

I don’t look down on non-frum Jews in general and never indicated as such. I do look down on those that could so carelessly and callously shed all vestiges of our holy religion under the guise of “mental illness caused them to”.

“Do you need to feel superior than them for your ego?”

This is not the first time you attacked me regarding my opinion where I don’t agree with you. I think you need to work on your ego first and maybe your urge to attack others who have a different opinion than yours will recede.

“No one is condoning their behavior, but they have to realize whatever the reason -the benefit of being Frum outweighs that reason! “

And therefore I need to agree that there OTD behavior stems from mental health? What’s the connection?