I always wondered why we weren’t supposed to argue with an apikoros?
Are you actually calling me an apikorus because I didn’t want to copy a book???!!
because they distort words, lie, and always feel the need to win!
I may be mistaken, but I don’t think I’ve lied. Don’t ascribe to malice what you can ascribe to ignorance.
And, lastly, I have no desire to feel that I have to win. I’ve conceded defeat on matters on these boards and others before.
does he quote someone who says you can’t? NO
does he say some ppl say you can’t? NO
Fair enough… but he also doesn’t give a firm yes. His using the terms “one should ask a Rav” clearly says to me that there is a possibility of the answer being no.
plans for reprinting, all one has to do is call the publisher and ask are you reprinting this?
Actually, if you read my post, you’d see that I did that (well, actually I emailed them). They no longer had the rights — but that doesn’t mean that the rights holders might not have plans to republish with a different publisher.
Ah, but what the heck. If I’m an apikorus, then it’s probably better that I didn’t copy and re-learn R. Berkovitz’s sefer and besmirch his Torah, right?
The Wolf
The post that this post is in reply to has been deleted, If you would like this post to also be deleted please inform us.