Reply To: Non-Jewish Jewish Music

Home Forums Music Non-Jewish Jewish Music Reply To: Non-Jewish Jewish Music



It’s actually a Chassidish concept that you can be “Metaher” the goysih music; Mashma that the original is a problem (Not (lev) Tahor?)

You won’t find anything in poskim because most of them hold music is Assur across the board, some of them even without instuments. It is the modern non-live music that many do allow, due to it not being “halachic” music (the Gezaira did not encompass music from a machine, not an instrument) (and some B’Davka don’t, as they (Rav Shturnbuch?) hold the machine is an instrument, there is a thread already regarding this idea).