Working for two doctors in Brooklyn I will say Health Plus is your best bet. Many doctors and hospitals don’t accept americhoice and if they do many are dropping them. americhoice is badly managed and is notorious for taking back money from doctors even years after they have paid. It is very diffivult to find specialists that are good and take americhoice. Health plus is better to doctors so more accept it.
If I were you I would first find the drs I want to use and which insurance they accept. as long as your drs accepts the insurance you can’t go werong with it no matter which one it is.