Reply To: Chanuka Dvar Torah

Home Forums Bais Medrash Chanuka Dvar Torah Reply To: Chanuka Dvar Torah

#713194
Ramchas
Participant

What does MAKAB”I stand for?

Megillat Antyiochus (Ner 2 Pasuk 26) brings down that when Yochanan son of Matisyahu came back from the war he built a monument called: MAKAB”I MEMIT HACHAZAKIM.

Traditionally it’s taught to stand for Hashem’s name as in Mi Khamocha Ba…

Here is a novel interpretation based on a different version of the Megilla that adds: he built a monument ‘to his name’ (Al Sh’mo) called MAKAB”I…

According to this version it seems that he was referring to his acronyms: Matisyahu Kohen Ben Yochanan.

The problem though is that we’re dealing with Yochanan the son of Matisyahu and not the opposite!

Comes the Mishna in Gittin 87a (Perek 9 Mishna 6) to the rescue…

It tells us that Yevanim had a different way of signing a Get.

By them, Reuven Ben Shimon meant: the son of Reuven is, Shimon!

We could then very well conceived that Yochanan also signed his name like his contemporary Yevanim: Matisyahu Kohen Ben, is Yochanan!!