Tag frowns on taking girls from out of the area as do many other local schools. Shevach is a great school and has many teachers from the FR area. The Krohns (as in Rabbi Pesach Khron and his wife) are very involved in the school. Ask in your own shul where the girls go and then hang around the schools and see for yourself what type of girls and families belong to those schools.
Another greaat High School for girls is Manhattan High School. It has a very well rounded program including Music (literally musical instruments), choir, etc. if your daughter doesn’t mind the ride into the city. Really a top notch high school.