YWN inserted my comments ,but they were truncated. The words on the present comment did not sound as harsh as the words are now. I said to “observateen’ that he should substantiate the quote from R’s.r.Hirsch, Otherwise he would be “insulting” a godol bejisroel- meaning R.S.R hirsch.
Actually, IF there is such a quote it clearly refers to R’Zvi Hirsch kalisher’s attempt to restore “korbonos’ on the Har Habaiys.ON THIS point, there were strong diasgreements between the gedolim of that dor-including R’akiva Eiger and the Chassam Sofer. On that- i can see Rav Hirsch saying what “observateen” mentioned, as it possibly included d’oraisas. It certainly had nothing to do with the ‘sholosh shevuos”.
Itche srulik= the sefer is called “derishas zion”. I’ll try to quote the relevant passages.