Reply To: ???? on women. Not trolling this time.

Home Forums Controversial Topics ???? on women. Not trolling this time. Reply To: ???? on women. Not trolling this time.

#766051
pascha bchochma
Participant

“That may no longer be the case; women now outnumber men in all levels of higher education enrollment.”

Yes, but that level drops once you reach actual achievement in the field. Those at the top of any scientific field are generally male.

“It doesn’t seem to have hurt Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Sonia Sotomayor, or Elana Kagan. They may all be postmenopausal, though. In any case, in a universally accepted tshuvah, Rav Uziel z’tz’l pointed out that a woman CAN be a Dayan on a beit din for a property dispute as long as both parties to the case accept here. That has not happened since no woman has earned yadin yadin semichah but it might at some point in the future.”

OK, but for life and death and things that are morally reprehensible, a person who MAY be emotionally affected shouldn’t be judging the case.

“All the rishonim were writing for men, as women didn’t have opportunity to learn Torah back then. Baruch HaShem that has changed! In any case, medieval Christian and Muslim attitudes towards women were far more negative.”

If his wife had been reading it, I have a feeling it would have been worded somewhat differently. That doesn’t mean it’s not essentially true.