Reply To: The Great Debate: Ultra-Orthodoxy vs. Modern Orthodoxy

Home Forums Controversial Topics The Great Debate: Ultra-Orthodoxy vs. Modern Orthodoxy Reply To: The Great Debate: Ultra-Orthodoxy vs. Modern Orthodoxy

#798678
RSRH
Member

Toi: The Artscroll biography is good history, but to really understand R. Hirsh’s hashkafa, one needs to study his writings ( a bit daunting, but start with the Nineteen Letters, and continue to Horeb, the Collected Writings, The Commentary on Chumash, Tehilim, and the Siddur – it took me three years to work through all of them thoroughly). While R. Klugman (the author of the Artscroll biography) is a fine historian and talmid chacham, his treatment of R. Hirsh’s philosophy in the biography is necessarily brief and overly-simplified.