Reply To: Modern Orthodoxy at a crossroads

moshemes, I can very well think that he is arguing on the Rambam- it’s black-and-white, as well as the tur and shulchan aruch in choshen mishpat. They all say “no”. I am not a lawyer, but the “no really meant yes” defense never works in secular court either.

Sam2,

1. No such R’ soloveitchik and 2. no such “daas yachid”, unless you mean daas Echad Yachid Umeyuchad.