Reply To: Please vote. Who is correct?

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Please vote. Who is correct? Reply To: Please vote. Who is correct?

#818239
bpt
Participant

Funny you should mention the kugel row issue. We make the Erev Shabbos kugel in a Pyrex loaf pan.

I feel it should be cut side-to-side in a rectangle.

My wife say it needs to be cut in a square, just like its done in shul.

I say, its only cut into a square in shul, because the pan is 11 x 17, so you cannot make a reasonable square in a commercial setting.

She says, no, kugel must be square, regardless of the pan size.

I tried to argue that a square leaves more exposed to dry up, but from a surface perspective, the cut area is the same in a square as it is in a rectangle (on a loaf pan). So that argument went nowhere.

So…Who is right?