Sam2: that is the opinion of the Rashba, and it is quoted by the Shach in 2 places. However, on the ???? ??? thread I quoted a long list of Poskim who disagree. They include Tosafos, the Smak, Issur v’Heter HaAruch, Rema, Maharshal, Pri Chadash, other Shachs and the Chavos Da’as.
Menu