Reply To: The Unspoken Promise

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee The Unspoken Promise Reply To: The Unspoken Promise


Doesnt the gemara tell us that Acher had the same problem addressed by the OP, (or was it Tzadok and Baytus)? He/they witnessed someone performing the mitzvah of kibbud av and shiluach hakan, mitzvos the torah says straight out “viharachta yamim” and the person fell off the ladder and died, whereupon he/they “concluded” Les Din Vles Dayan”? It is not a new phenomenom.