Reply To: (??????? (????? ?????

Sam2-

Because the mamashus is not nikkar and there is no ta’am. My rosh chaburah brough a Sheilas Ya’avetz who is talking about something else and writes that the ???? left on a kli is not considered mamasho shel issur, but rather it is subject to rules of ta’am.

Jothar –

I do not agree with you. ????? ????? means you asked him to do it, as we pasken in 122 that ?? ????? ??? ?? ?????? ???? ????? ????? ???. And even the Maharshal, who adds the case where you didn’t ask for it, is only machmir where you want it.

Steam Jackets: My fist question is who says it’s a ben yomo? And even if you know that it was, that would only be for the first few batches, why would you not say ??? ???? ???? ?”? on the rov, which would be matir all of the bottles you find in the store?

3 large pieces of steak, 1 is treif, and they are ??”?: If it’s treif because of a bli’a. Also if it’s only a chumra R’ Akiva Eiger says it’s batul.

Purposely diluting milk in water: The Shach from the Toras Chatas is mashma that it’s assur (even though it’s mutar l’chatchila to put it into the meat after the fact). I heard that R’ Akiva Eiger is matir. My rav writes that from the rishonim it’s mevuar that it’s mutar, see here: http://hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=1525&st=&pgnum=274.