PBA: Find me once where I personally claimed that. I explained what the opinion and the Tzad of those against MBP are. That’s it. I personally think the whole controversy is entirely overblown. Mohalim just need to make sure they’re not sick and should clean their mouths before doing MBP. (I do, however, think that a Mohel who has herpes and an open wound/cold sore and is going to do MPB anyway has the Din of a Rodeph, which is not at all a radical opinion. I think everyone agrees that someone with herpes and a cold sore shouldn’t do MPB and puts the baby in tremendous danger for no reason.)
Menu