Reply To: Heteirim for Copying and giving out Music

Tnai? Its only a binding tnai if the seller will refund the buyers payment if the tnai is broken (i.e. a copy is made), as that is the recourse for a broken tnai. Since the producer and retailer won’t accept a return and refund the cost of the CD if the buyer breaks the tnai, the tnai is unenforceable and effectively there is no tnai.