Reply To: Beis Din of America

Of course it is reliable, except I believe it fails on two fronts. Rabbi Hershel Schachter advocates 2 positions I believe are anti-halakhic. First, get meusa. The ORA crowd coerces gittin. This is no good. Second issue is geirus. The mekoros are pretty clear that conversion is not to be handled by mega batei din, but by any beis din of three shomrei shabbos men. They impose too many standards external of what is actuallly required m’ikar hadin. They turn away sincere people and are guilty of innui hager.