Zees: None of your points are inherently wrong. But when you take things too far you hurt your own points and you insult others. By making it seem that your opinion (and the opinion of those Gedolim and Poskim you follow) is the only “Torah true” opinion, you cut yourself off from the part of the Klal that disagrees with you. Machlokes is supposed to be Marbeh Shalom, not Sinah and division. Eilu V’eilu is more than just an important Halachic concept. It’s a way of life. Now, one has to be very careful in knowing which opinions are valid and fall under Eilu V’eilu and which opinions don’t fall under the framework of valid Halachic positions. But more valid positions exist than just your own.
Menu