Also, he make sno mention of any Minhag.
?????? ???? ?’ ??? ????”? ?????? ????
He is clearly referring to 1:45 and 46
He’s not. His talmid, Rabbi Moishe Dovid Lebovits, considered his opinion in the teshuva (45) to be, “isn’t so sure” (that it’s assur). I have another basis for knowing that it’s not based on this teshuva, but it’s not a citable source.
http://www.thehalacha.com/attach/Volume5/Issue15.pdf
??? ?????? ??? ????? ?? ???? ????? ????? ??? ?? ????, ??? ??? ???? ?????
He would say that on the Mahara”m Schick and Lechem Haponim?
while the format is less than ideal and talking face-to-face is more productive, it does have advantages. This way, each side has time to look up sources and contemplate their position in between rejoinders, something difficult when debating in person.
In any event, while not a perfect venue, debating Torah certainly beats discussing mundane topics.
I agree (and I will try to review and contemplate that Sha”ch again 🙂 ).
???? ??? on your response in the “speechless” thread.