Reply To: Bishul Akum?

Home Forums Controversial Topics Bishul Akum? Reply To: Bishul Akum?

#883326
uneeq
Participant

Health-how come Hello99 & DY are speaking to the issue and not you? Since you ran out what to answer you resort to rank outs.

I responded to you no less than 3 times. If you count the responses of the others, you have been responded and answered correctly more than 10 times. I am surprised that they haven’t run out of patience yet. It’s about time that you wake up. Others have complained about you in other places about this same exact issue. (see latest post in kanoyim campain by BTguy)

Parts of 3 different posts-

1) There are at least a couple issues at hand-

1) issur bishul of the heating elements

2) issur bishul of the cholent

You may argue that the heating elements don’t reach the deoraysa -glowing red hot- level, although according to the famous chazon ish, “chatzi shiur m’doraysa” and therefore even if it will never glow its still an Issur deoraysa. etc…

2) The problem of amira leakum is simpler. You cannot tell a goy to do a melacha for you on shabbos.

So as long as it’s not fully cooked, or it’s cold, it would be a definite Issur. etc…

3) Health- I mentioned what you said over here already (see right below). Although as DY points out, there is still an Issur of bishul. I pointed that out too. Only if it’s fully cooked AND still not-cold/hot will it be muttar to tell a goy. etc…

Almost as mature as any member of the Sikrikim whom you said that you hope they all are jailed.

Nice misquote of what I said. All I mentioned there is that its good that one of the bullys is off the local streets. I never said that I was happy that he’s in jail. And I never said all the sikrikim should be thrown in jail, even though that might bring the geula faster than I can pack my luggages.