DaasYochid -“Health: “Since when is a coil -Aish?”
Achiezer, and pretty much universally accepted since. Vadai and not Safek.”
Such Naarishkeit! How could the Achronim say Vaday? I’m sure they don’t say Vaday -they just say Ossur. This has to be because of Sofek! Did they have electric burners in the Mishkon?
“The Temperature is irrelevant. Anything over Yad Soledes is Bishul Min HaTorah.”
Then you post this which you just contradict yourself:
“Actually, the Gemara says it’s only d’Rabannan. However, many Achronim explain the reason is due to a distinction in the quality of the output; solar heat will not cook as well as fire.”
So which one is it? Yad Soledes or cooked as well? You obviously don’t think before you post! Cooking in a crock pot doesn’t cook as well as a fire -that’s why it takes so long. Same with sand!
If you weren’t so sure that you are never wrong -you wouldn’t have wrote what you did. You assume an electric burner is the same as a crock pot. Who told you to assume this? An electric burner would be Ossur D’oraysa if the food reaches Yad Soledes. (Because of Sofek.) A crock pot would only be Ossur D’oraysa if it cooks as well as fire and it doesn’t!
“you suffer from Kaas also!!!
That isn’t Kaas! Didn’t you read the title of the topic? It says Kanoyim. That is Kanoyis!!
I totally lost any respect for you after this last post. Don’t respond to be again in this topic unless you have something new to say. Repeating the same dribble over and over again -only makes you right (or more right) in your mind only!