Reply To: Bishul Akum?

Home Forums Controversial Topics Bishul Akum? Reply To: Bishul Akum?

#883442
Health
Participant

DY -“That’s true, there should be no difference, but either way, you seem to have missed the word “occasionally (lif’omim)” which means it doesn’t happen all the time.”

An unavoidable situation that happens all the time even if it doesn’t happen every single week -would Not be Mutter L’Tzorech Godol. Find other ways than Ameira L’acum to solve your problem. This is exactly why Chazal Assured Ameira L’acum in the first place.

I’ll try: The M”B says that there is more reason to be machmir on hanaah from food, because one has a strong desire for it, than from other types of hanaah.

A little more explanation, please?

“It’s not 100%, you’re right, but in most cases, the fire going out means no cholent.”

In order to bring a Raya -it has to be 100%. Btw, your case of fire going out happens all the time in EY. (Gas goes out.) And all they do is bring it to a neighbor. This is something that happens all the time. I can’t see anybody saying call a Goy. This isn’t the type of case where they said Mutter because of Tzorech Godol. They know this happens quite often.