DY -“the MB says the Mechaber doesn’t hold of this Taam.
Because we don’t have to assume it was raw, but raw, inedible foods are muktzah.
Because who is doing the cooking? The goy is. In my case it’s the Jew.”
What – you don’t know basic Halachos of Muktza? When the Goy is cooking the food it’s not on your mind so it’s Muktza. If you cook it (even through a goy) then it’s on your mind and it’s not Muktza. Just as a Raya that your writing Shtus -the PHS writes Vol. 3 Chap.6 #18 (E) -“The food in the crock pot must be completely cooked or completely raw -i.e. -the raw food should be placed in the pot as close as possible to Shabbos.”
What happened to Muktza? How can you eat this food?
“I misunderstood your case; if you did the cooking, then I guess you were oiver an issur d’oraiso.”
Ha Ha -You’re a stand up comic. ROTFL! Then again all your “Halacha” posts are very funny/amusing.
“But he says/brings many cases of Ameira L’acum that he is Matir in situations of Tzorech Godol. Check it out!”
“As I said, there was no answer.”
The Debrecener brings other cases of Tzorech Godol which pushes off Ameira L’acum even where the Melecha is D’oraysa! Not just by Kovod Habrious!
“If the R’ma were mattir a d’oraiso for the mitzvah of oneg Shabbos, this would be true even for a healthy adult.”
It is true in a case of Tzorech Godol, but the case of the Koton is just a Tzorech, not a Tzorech Godol. If the case was what you are presuming that the Koton is starving -then this would be – Sakana Nefoshos. A little kid can’t fast a whole day. The case is talking about the kid is being picky – even so Ameira L’acum is Mutter because a kid has a Din of a Choleh Shain Bo Sakana. The way you learn up S’A is amazing. You put in Pshat into cases that it doesn’t say and then you use them as Rayos to say I’m wrong.
How could you say that the Koton really has nothing else to eat, but this isn’t considered Pikuach Nefesh?
“Tzorech Shabbos is Not Tzorech Godol!
Then I guess you didn’t have a tzorech gadol.”
Sometimes Tzorech Shabbos can be Tzorech Godol -like in my case, but not all the time!