DY -“I don’t understand your point; are you claiming that raw, inedible food is not muktzeh?”
When you plan on using this raw food -it’s not Muktza.
Did you ever learn Hilchos Muktza?
“Then you have no right to extrapolate to your case, as per the M”A I quoted earlier.”
I have every right.
“one still cannot extrapolate from one case to another. The Mogen Avraham says this regarding a shvus (307:7) and it would certainly apply to a d’oraiso.”
Another misinterpretation on your part! I’ll even explain why! What’s the problem with learning one Shvus to another? Simple because not every Shvus has the same reason why it’s Ossur -so you can’t learn one from another. On the other hand -if something is a D’oraysa and the Goy can do this D’oraysa for a Jew on Shabbos, then they can do any D’oraysa for the Jew as long as the circumstances didn’t change.
“That doesn’t answer my question.”
And I thought I did! If You Want to Clearly Elaborate what you mean -I’ll try to explain it better.