Reply To: Infertility treatments – Tzedaka??

Home Forums Controversial Topics Infertility treatments – Tzedaka?? Reply To: Infertility treatments – Tzedaka??

#883868
Health
Participant

DY -“and click on the words this article, footnote 6..

Sorry, I guess I should have put arrows to make it more clear.”

I did it and it worked. I guess I’m very ignorant in HTML. I never thought you could click on words that aren’t highlighted. I guess we learn new things every day.

“Good for him, because the Gr”a does not argue on the priority of Torah, only beis haknesses. I did see it myself, I’m not relying on that article, but he has some nice mareh m’komos, so I linked it.

According to you, Health, the author didn’t merely commit an error of omission, he switched the whole order around! You are entitled to argue if you want (in the realm of discussion; for halacha l’maaseh ask your rov), but I don’t understand how you can say he did a good job if you think he reversed the order of priority.”

Well I thought he (the author) was going acc. to the Mechaber.

I don’t see how you can learn differently in the Gr’a than I posted. The Yerushalmi doesn’t say outright a Halacha that those 3 things come before Tzedaka. It’s a Diyuk from the Yerushalmi & the Gr’a says it’s No Diyuk. So how could anyone derive it’s only about a Shul acc. to the Gr’a? It’s possible the mistake is that you & him are focusing on the Gr’a’s word of “Kol Shkain with our Geersa” and ignoring “Aino Muchrach”.