Reply To: Matisyahu – what are you doing with his cds?

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Matisyahu – what are you doing with his cds? Reply To: Matisyahu – what are you doing with his cds?

#886201
BTGuy
Participant

musicaldignity?

Excuse me?

Nonjewish music?

Here are three points to ponder:

1. I have heard from reliable sources that music (not lyrics) is not considered non-Jewish unless it makes you dance to a certain degree, of which does not happen these days.

2. I have heard from reliable sources that many of the tunes we sing in shul may have originated from places like the Polish military, secular songs in Europe, and even choir or church-like music.

3. I know many reliable sources, as frum as can be, who like classical music EVEN if the composer was an antisemite.

Ok..another point to ponder: Being a BT…I cannot tell you how many songs I hear on Jewish radio where the musicians are throwing in instrumentation directly from the Beatles, Eric Clapton, Rod Stewart, and other such artists. In fact, if they studied music formally, they would almost have had to learn those guitar and piano riffs from a legitimate teacher.

So…….