Zdad,
You say “These are 2 well known stories, Both were in the regular newspapers and you can believe or not believe either of them.” (BTW, I doubt that either are really well known stories, perhaps just in your mind)
Which is in direct contradiction with what you said initially “I am sure the same people who are calling this a “Bubba Meinser” are the same people who claim the Fish in Monsey talked.”
Perhaps Bubbe Meisner confused you with some of her Grandson’s excellent fish. Or more likely you ate some old fish didn’t agree with and it talked back.
But you should believe both stories because they are both on the internet, the source of all good things true.