Reply To: Why are some Jews against Israel?

Home Forums Eretz Yisroel Why are some Jews against Israel? Reply To: Why are some Jews against Israel?

#913208
Health
Participant

Avi K -“Health,

1. I am realy tired of this yes they did/no they didn’t argument about the rov. I dispute you.”

And I’m tired of your Zionist propaganda!

“2. The Satmar Rebbe in fact admitted that he was a daat yachid but denied that we go according to the rov because there was no meeting or quorum.”

He was only a “Daas Yochid” (which he really isn’t) in ignoring the Medina right now, but not that the Medina is a good thing.

“3. In any case, the rov can be wrong.If they are the halacha is reversed and they and those who went according to their pesak bring ????? Rambam Hilchot Shiggot ch. 12).Write down your debt in your notebook.”

And how do you know they are Wrong? Do you have Nevuah? So this is exactly the Din of Rov – when Gedolim/Poskim are arguing and you don’t know who to follow -you go after the Rov!

“4. The Medina has been established. Today nobody outside of the NK quacks is against it.”

More Propaganda! Almost all the Gedolim are against it, but the question is what to do about it now. A lot of Gedolim hold we should have Political Parties to try and put some Yiddiskeit into the Medina! There are quite a few like Satmar and Brisk that say have nothing to do with them – Don’t take their money and Don’t vote for anyone!