Reply To: Giyoress or Not?

Home Forums Controversial Topics Giyoress or Not? Reply To: Giyoress or Not?

#913586
yytz
Participant

The practice of invalidating someone’s conversion because the ger was not observant enough afterward is extremely new. Yet nowadays even anonymous online commentators feel entitled to passul someone’s gerus! Heaven help us.

Can anyone provide an example of a rabbi or beis din invalidating someone’s conversion because of a lack of complete observance, that occurred before the late 20th century? I believe that’s when this innovation began.