Reply To: Ah Gutten Erev Shabbos

Home Forums Shabbos! Ah Gutten Erev Shabbos Reply To: Ah Gutten Erev Shabbos

#914862
Health
Participant

nishtdayngesheft -“No that is not what you said, what you actually said was “It comes from “1” Rosh Hayeshiva -so if you’re his Talmid..”. The emaphasis on 1 is yours, not mine nor from any one else. Not that you know of one Rosh Hayeshiva, rather that there is only one. Which you are obviously incorrect about.”

And what I meant was, since you have to nitpick, that this Chumra came about as far as I know, from 1 RY, not that long ago, who was Mechadesh it. It doesn’t mean noone else keeps this Chumra that this RY was Mechadesh, whether they are RY’s or not. Now put all my posts together and see if it makes sense? I didn’t think I had to spell everything out. If you Still need futher clarification, I’m not like Chazal -you can still ask the Mechaber.

“Besides the OP asked if there is any inyan for saying a gutten erev shabbos, which you eventually turned into someone being megalleh ponim batorah sheloh kehallacha.”

No, he turned it into this. Reread my posts and his.

“Your intolerance of another’s opinion is disturbing. To the point that any small sort of logic you may have had flies right out the window. And it is something you do consistently. On another thread you were already were passuling the geirus of someone based on something you think you saw while eating in a restaurant. And there are a myriad other examples.

Perhaps this midah contributes to your current situation. You should seek help in rectifying it, you may find yourself to be much happier.”

I’m happy when I point out fallacies in certain posters. You might enjoy putting me down, but if you don’t like my posts bring logic to argue. Since you aren’t able to, how about admitting you’re wrong? By your constant put-downs – this is more of a reflection of you than of me!